Further Considerations Regarding Fragments
"Four Propositions on Psychoanalysis", Deleuze does not consider
psychiatry as such, but some arguments hold true of it in modified form,
& relate to Chesler's book.
psychoanalysis stifles the production of desire. Psychiatry attacks the
brain's chemistry to render desire an achievement. As a victim of
mismedication, Chesler writes of the mental hospital in "Down and Out in
Muncie, Indiana" - as an artist, we do not want to stifle & conquer
the alleged unconscious, we must produce it - & it is not easy to
create this infantile world, but it is our duty. Fascist psychiatrists
may believe that they mean well, but as Bukowski notes: there are no
good cops. Chesler's desire was stifled before then, deviated &
suppressed, but it sought itself in art, it found itself in me. In the
story in question, she is seen as surrounded by pointless ciphers, each
of them barely human, vermin. The mentally ill, the Herr Doktors, &
the fascist camp guards on the medical staff all played out their
allotted roles, like all the unintelligent they were unable to be
outside of their clearly delimited borders.
psychoanalysis abuses language, it keeps people from speaking, it takes
away the conditions of true expression, & thus it stifles
utterances, that strive to be indefinites, infinitives, proper names of
becomings. Psychoanalysis separates the expressing subject from the
subject of the utterance, Chesler does not try to speak her "I", except
in the meta-level excerpts alluded to in the previous analysis of the
work. She even masquerades this alleged "I" through the character "I" –
she subverts the entire psychiatric/psychoanalytic subversion of thought
by assuming the "I" as a proper name. The establishment uses personal
pronouns as weapons; they are part of its rape kit. The psychiatrist
sees the patient as part of an anonymous group categorized, in this
case, as "bipolar I" – this is horseshit. Each of them, these various
victims, is a unique name, indicating a haecceitas.
psychiatry, like psychoanalysis, destroys utterance & desire by a
machine that interprets, & a machine that subjectivises its
subjects. They, this enemy, tell you who you are. Chesler defies the
process by the representation of an irreducible intensity, though this
book is full of placeholders, wasting space while an equal awaited her
unknowing, so the irreducible intensity is a failure & a sense of
despite, of disgust, spitting arrogant hatred at eyes that are full of
junk & nothingness.
psychoanalysis involves power relationships. Now this is doubly true of
the psychiatric institution. Chesler's current psychiatrist, whom we
call Dr. Bunghole in our texts about him, is a moron who actually
boasted that his IQ was 130 to her, as if this were impressive. This
ludicrous arrogance stems from the fact that the branch of the police
called psychiatry is a medium of social control. It exacts an enforced
docility from the unruly bodies of the insane by the brutality of the
anti-psychotic. Chesler narrates in the story in question of a cretinous
nurse who behaved like a camp guard, a scumbag.
should reveal truth, should indicate it & engage in the strenuous
activity of thought, says Heidegger. This Chesler does.
The expanded & improved 2nd edition of Fragments by Jennifer S. Chesler is now at Barnes & Noble at this link . Several pieces a...
Written by David C. McLean Jennifer S. Chesler & I have produced quite a few books recently. Her Fragments is now available in a seco...
Fragments is a book by Jennifer S. Chesler that is soon to be released in a 2nd edition containing quite a large number of new and redisco...
Fragments is the third written, but first published, of Jennifer S. Chesler’s four novels to date. Fragments has the form of an antholo...